2/18/10

PROs & CONs of a Grid

Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of using grids. Should they be used at all?

Of course grids should be used. They create structure and consistency in design. While they do create rules, rules can be broken. Who is the designer anyway? Subdividing or modifying the grid could also be a useful solution if the structure of a grid seems to interfere with the flow of the design. In the end a grid is not much more than are a guide, a direction, a way to establish consistency and in a timely manor. It is a perfect tool to help utilized the design space. They are a great way to create structure and harmony in a design.

In some situations if the grid is blocking a creative concept, of course, throw it out! There have been times that I have been so excited about a concept I dive right in and put the concept down. A great example of this is when I am working on logos and even websites. I know in the end in web development a grid is key, but when trying to design and break out of the uniform expected structure, working through concepts without a grid can be very beneficial.

Another personal example of how a grid can be a disadvantage is I currently work with one client who likes all his designs very loose and unstructured. In fact when I started working with him, I had to make lots of revisions to designs due to the fact that I had most of the layout in a solid grid. Even though the now the finished product is usually unbalanced, chaotic, and lacking structure he is delighted. Is the customer always right?

Resources:
AIO Lecture Week 1
Design School 3rd edition –pgs 17,18,19,140
http://webdesign.about.com/od/layout/qt/why_grids.htm
http://graphicdesign.about.com/od/layout/a/grid_system.htm
http://v3.markboulton.co.uk/articles/detail/why_use_a_grid/

GRID Webpage VS Newspaper

Are certain grid applications better for one type of product or service over another? In your opinion, why is this so?

Webpage VS Newspaper
A great example of one grid application that is ideal in one situation and completely inappropriate in another is a web page grid verses a newspaper grid. In a newspaper there is mostly heavy sections of copy that are displayed in multiple spaced columns. A webpage is completely different where a grid to divide up the page for navigation, content and in some cases advertising.

When I worked for an online adverting agency, at one time we were discussing the grid used in classified papers and applying that to our classified website design. While it sounded good in theory, having the same “look” as classifieds in the paper, applying that design to a website was very difficult. The main issue I remember is the user would be continually scrolling down the page reading the narrow column.

To answer the question "Are certain grid applications better for one type of product or service over another?" Defiantly!

Resources:
AIO Lecture Week 1
Design School 3rd edition –pgs 17,18,19,140
http://960.gs/
http://tutorialblog.org/grid-systems-in-web-design/
http://graphicdesign.spokanefalls.edu/tutorials/tech/column_inches/col_inches.htm

Grids?

What grids appear to work most flexibly, most creatively, most productively? In your opinion, why is this so?

The rule of balance and principal of thirds I think create the most flexible and creative grid for productivity. As the lecture pointed a grid will “narrow the "creative options"” By using one of these two principles for layouts creates many opportunities, as it is a limited amount of structure and control. The possibilities are endless. At the same time, while this limited structure will open creativity and flexibility, it is probably not the best choice for productivity. Using a grid with more structure and control will save time and as the lecture also stated, "things are falling together nicely." With a more structured grid, like a nine column grid, the decisions have been made which will ensure a more consistent design.

Resources:
AIO Lecture Week 1
Design School 3rd edition –pgs 17,18,19,140
http://desktoppub.about.com/od/designprinciples/l/aa_balance4.htm

2/17/10

When Readability Is Not Important! WHAT!!!

Discuss, giving examples, some graphic communications for which "readability" might not be so important.

A. Company>Product>Web Address…
In this ad I found for Sweet Protection. My eye was drawn to the main elements of the contrasting red log, to the silhouette of the skier in an extreme jumping position, then to the bold white text “RAMBLER” above the helmet and finally to the web address in bold white text below. I see there is also text in between the Rambler and web address but it is very light and hard to read. I actually can’t make out a single word. In this case the important informing text are very visible and readable, but the “noise” text is washed into the design.


here is another ad for Sweet Protection I found.


B. Repetition:
Here is a layout that is using repetition of the word “Yes”. My eye visually went to the large “Yes” that is located on the upper right side of the page. At first glance I didn’t read all the other “Yes’s” but I knew they were saying the same thing even though they are in different fonts. Some are cropped off the page leaving only the top of the word or even just the “y”. We still know it stands for “Yes” because of the repetition.


C. Text for Graphic Assimilation.
YOU MUST CHECK THIS ONE OUT!!!!
Applying text with flash media. The text here is used as an element to create the leaves on the tree. Give it a minute; the text is layered making it in some places not readable. When it is done loading, DON”T FORGET TO CLICK ON THE RIGHT “DAY MODE” TAB. Very cool. I love the look of the light green text overlapping. The application is perfect for leaves. So inspiring!!! You have to go there!
https://www.ecotonoha.com/ecotonoha.html



Resources:
AIO Lecture
Typographic Design Form and Communication
http://www.redrabbits.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/10/sweet-ad-rambler2.jpg
http://www.redrabbits.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/10/sweet-ad-rambler-snowboard.jpg
http://www.oi-you.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/cg-yes1.jpg
https://www.ecotonoha.com/ecotonoha.html

"Type Reflects Personality"

Justify the statement, 'Type reflects our personality'.

I found a great little article by Dave Murphy called, “Choice of Typeface Reveals Personality Traits”. In the article he list two great examples of how Sir Edward George, the Governor of the bank of England deliberately used Courier typeface due to his opinion that he didn’t need to consider the emotional need of others. The other example listed is the Prince of Wales, who preferred to use modern Helvetica to allude to the idea that he was in touch with the times. Both of these examples are perfect justification of the statement in question.

At the same, time I understand that there are those who would argue, “What about default fonts?” The teenage boy that uses Times New Roman on his book report and the 80 year old that uses the same font to write his granddaughter. Does this font reflect their personality? Of course this great generation gap and use of this font does through a monkey wrench into the mix. But, I would venture to say that in both of these instances the font was left to the default because both of these individuals could have personalities that don’t like change. They are not looking to try something new, or be creative. They are using this default font because it “works for them”… so why would they change it. Even in this instance the statement is still true!

Resources:
AIO Lecture
http://www.dgl.com/itinfo/2001/it010530a.html
http://www.minnpost.com/christinacapecchi/2008/01/09/534/typography_psychology_what_does_your_typeface_say_about_you
http://www.blurtit.com/q2884357.html

Legibility Is It Important?

Discuss that legibility is an important aspect of typographic design by illustrating the works of some leading type designers.

In most cases we are using typography to communicate information. If that information cannot be read or interpreted the intended message is lost or it looses it’s readability. Most of the time legibility will impact not only interpretation, but also the speed of interpretation. These two flavors, legibility and readability, are the key ingredients to the clarity of typography.

Legibility is referring to the ease of discerning one letter from another. Readability is referring more to how the typeface is used and how easily words, phrases or sections of type can be read.

Claude Garamond, worked as an apprentice punch-cutter / printer in 1510. He was a Frenchman developed his Garamond type off the roman font Griffo. At one point he grew so popular with his successful type designs in Europe that King Francois I, demanded that he develop a Greek typeface, which later was knows as “Grecs du Roi”. Today reading Garamond text on a page still requires little effort. Garamond is well known for his use by book designers for over 450 years.

Garamond is also found in many advertisements today. Here are a few:
Abercrombie & Fitch
Motrin
Neutrogena
Apple
http://www.pointlessart.com/education/loyalist/typeTalk/garamond/present.html

Resources:
http://www.typophile.com/node/30388
http://www.fontbureau.com
http://www.fonts.com/aboutfonts/articles/typography/legibility.htm
http://www.pointlessart.com/education/loyalist/typeTalk/garamond/index2.html

Typography Convergence

Explain, giving examples, how convergence of design and technology has immensely increased the scope of typographic design.

When I consider that in the early days of type how each letter was carved or cast and then set up manually in a press, it just seems so ridged, concrete and so much more difficult to be creative. Sure you could adjust letting and kerning, but as far as going back in and changing the size or font on an individual letter, or line, that would mean resetting that line on the plate and repressing. Here I a picture of some on looking over bins of letter and setting up type.


As a designer today with millions of fonts available at my fingertips, I am amazed at what the process used to require. Today it is so easy to make adjustment to large sections of copy with a “command A” and few clicks of a mouse. Even take as website for example, you can adjust countless pages of copy through a single style sheet.

Technology has also enabled designers to use and in some cases abuse typeface like never before. When using a cast letter for printing, that was it. Now with graphic software we can do anything we want to the letter. Sometimes when I don’t like the look of a letter in a certain font, I can go in manually and change that letter myself no disrespect to the original designer, but sometimes it doesn’t look right.. Even great software like Adobe Illustrator has evolved over the past few years. Looking back to version 10 there was never a 3-D tool to quickly manipulate text into a 3d effect. I believe this tool started in CS, Illustrator 11.
The old way http://www.wowwebdesigns.com/power_guides/3d_text/
The new way: http://www.gomediazine.com/tutorials/create-dream-design-3d-typography/


Resources:
1. AIO Lecture
2. History and Foundations of Typography www.infoamerica.org/museo/pdf/evolucion.pdf
3. http://www.jimmydrobinson.com
4. http://www.gomediazine.com/tutorials/create-dream-design-3d-typography/
5. http://www.wowwebdesigns.com/power_guides/3d_text/
6. http://mediadesigner.digitalmedianet.com/articles/viewarticle.jsp?id=22141
7. http://www.wpdfd.com/issues/23/typography/

Good Typography Can Stand Alone

Good use of typography can always stand-alone. Experienced and knowledgeable designers can accomplish this as they understand how to unleash the power of emotion and appeal that typeface possesses. Great examples of this are McDonalds, as their Golden Arches are actually utilizing the letter “M” and their new logo is tagged with their phrase, “Im lovin it.”


Another great example is Google. While google does on occasion use symbol and images to celebrate events and holidays, for the most part Google is a typeface logo with a creative use of color. The text is very well know and can hold its own going solo.